Photography literally means “light writing”. It comes from the Greek language; phos meaning light and graphie meaning writing. Whether using film cameras or digital, light is the core ingredient that makes the photo. Cameras use a light meter to measure how much light is in the scene. In auto and semi-auto modes, the camera can’t tell if something is actually black and white so it tries to balance the exposure around the mid-tone which is neutral grey.
Auto/Semi-Auto Mode
First, I set my camera to Program Mode (P), a semi-automatic setting where the camera handles both aperture and shutter speed. I kept ISO at the default and made sure the exposure compensation was set to zero. I took three separate photos, framing each so that each tone, black, grey, or white) filled the viewfinder entirely.
When I reviewed the images, I noticed that all three looked fairly similar in brightness, despite their real-world differences. The black cloth looked too light, and the white paper looked duller and darker than expected. The histograms for each photo were also almost identical, clustered around the middle of the graph.






This made it clear: the camera’s light meter was trying to balance each scene to match a mid-tone grey, rather than recording the true tone of the subject. A black surface, a grey floor, and a white paper were all treated the same, even though they clearly weren’t.
Manual Mode
After testing in Program Mode, I switched my camera to Manual Mode (M). I set the ISO to 400 and the aperture to f/5.6, then adjusted the shutter speed for each photo until the exposure looked right in the viewfinder. I photographed the same three subjects, black cloth, grey floor, and white paper, framing them exactly as before.
This time, the results were much more accurate. The black cloth stayed dark, the grey floor appeared as a true mid-tone, and the white paper looked bright, just as I expected it to. When I checked the histograms, they clearly reflected these differences:
- The black cloth histogram sat further to the left.
- The grey floor was positioned neatly in the center.
- The white paper shifted further to the right.
Adjusting the exposure manually gave me much more control over the final image, and the histograms confirmed that the camera was now recording the tones correctly, rather than trying to average everything to a mid-grey.






Reflection
At first, I struggled to fully understand this exercise. It was hard to get my head around how the camera’s light meter interprets a scene and why the images looked so similar in auto mode, even though the subjects were completely different in real life.
Once I switched to manual mode and started adjusting the shutter speed myself, the results finally clicked into place. Seeing the histograms shift, with the black photo sitting to the left, the grey in the middle, and the white to the right, helped me understand how much control I actually have over exposure when I’m not relying on the camera to make decisions for me.
This exercise really highlighted the difference between allowing the camera to guess the exposure, and making those decisions as the photographer. Although it took me a bit of trial and error to work it out, it’s made me feel more confident using manual mode going forward, especially in situations where the lighting is consistent.






